Showing posts with label motion to vacate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label motion to vacate. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 16, 2019

A Bondsman, a Surety, and the People Walk into the Court of Appeal . . .

People v. Am. Surety Co., No. E067831 (D4d2 Jan. 15, 2019)

Under Code of Civil Procedure § 917.1, by posting an undertaking, a party can stay the enforcement of a money judgment pending appeal. If the judgment is affirmed and the defendant fails to satisfy, the surety pays the judgment and then becomes, in effect, the judgment creditor. But § 917.1 only applies to an appeal of a money judgment. 

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

Not Wrong Enought to Be Arbitration-Wrong

Baxter v. Block, No. A144112 (D1d1 May 24, 2016)

Attorney and Clients arbitrated a fee dispute under the Mandatory Fee Arbitration Act. The Arbitrator awarded $0, finding that Attorney’s services were worth less than he had billed. They were, instead, worth a lesser amount, which just happened to be exactly what Client had paid. 

But Clients hadn’t paid as much as the Arbitrator thought. He apparently relied on a mistaken document. Attorney noted the mistake. And Clients, to their credit, basically admitted it. But the Arbitrator refused to modify his award.
Attorney moved to vacate the award; Clients to confirm it. Clients also asked for their fees on confirmation, based on a fee provision in the retainer agreement. In addition to the payment mistake, Attorney claimed that Arbitrator had failed to disclose that a bunch of his recent work entailed auditing legal bills, which is Attorney claims is a significantly pro-client job for a fee arbitrator that it merited disclosure. The trial court refused to vacate the award on wither grounds and gave Clients their fees, although he cut their fee counsel’s hourly rates and hours significantly.

The court publishes its opinion only on the disclosure issue and the fee calculation. So far as the bill auditing (non-) disclosure goes, the record showed the arbitrator did a bunch of different consulting work around the issue of attorney fees. Some on the client-side like bill auditing. But also some on the attorney-side like testifying about reasonable rates for fee applications. His expertise was thus in billing issues in general, not in representing one side or another in fee disputes. Which meant his consulting work didn’t cause him to have a particular economic incentive to go one way or the other or to rule a certain way to garner the favor of future clients. Because the consulting didn’t create any reasonable doubt about the arbitrator’s impartiality, the judgment could not be vacated for failure to disclose, or to otherwise provide a grounds for disqualification.

And on the fees, Clients’ two attorneys billed Client—and Client sought fee recovery—at the same hourly rate. Both had roughly the same pedigrees and experience. Yet, the trial court gave only one of them a substantial rate cut without any explanation. The court finds this to be an abuse of discretion and sends the case back for an explanation. But it affirms the hours cut, deferring to the trial court’s judgment that the time billed was excessive for a motion to confirm an arbitration award. Such judgment can only be reversed if it is “clearly wrong,” which it wasn’t here.

Reversed in part.

Monday, February 8, 2016

(Re) Clearing the Decks

So I just moved, we are expecting a second daughter in May, and I have spent the last month pulling all-nighters in expedited preliminary injunction proceedings. Which is all a way to say that I’ve fallen really behind on posts here. 

Friday, June 5, 2015

More Non-Judgment Judgments

Lee v. Silveira, No. F067723 (D5 as modified June 8, 2015)
 

A PI plaintiff makes a § 998 offer of judgment for a million dollars. Defendant does not accept. The verdict was more than $1 million, but the court reduced the award under Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc., 52 Cal. 4th 541, 548 (2011), which says the plaintiff is entitled to a damages award in the amount of her paid medical bills, not the amounts first billed, because the bills have no relationship with economic reality. After the reduction, the award dropped below $1 million. It is pretty clear that had the jury been asked calculate damages under Howell, the plaintiff wouldn’t have beaten the offer and thus couldn’t shift her substantial expert costs to defendant. The fact that the trial court did so post-hoc shouldn’t lead to a different result. The court so holds.

The court goes on to address a second issue regarding post-judgment procedure. Like a lot of post-judgment issues, it turns on the timing of the judgment. The jury’s original verdict was reflected in a document called “Judgment on Jury Verdict,” which, notwithstanding its title, specifically noted that it was subject to post-trial adjustments for the medical expenses and prejudgment interest. Defendants moved to reduce the “judgment” for the delta between the paid and billed expenses. Plaintiff did not contest the adjustment, but argued that prejudgment interest and her expert fees should be tacked on before the court made the adjustment. The court agreed with plaintiff and ultimately entered a new, final judgment that included the interest and fees.  Defendant then moved under Code of Civil Procedure § 663 to vacate the judgment and enter a new one.

Plaintiff argued that the first “Judgment on Jury Verdict” was a bona fide judgment and thus should have been attacked by a motion for new trial. So when Defendant’s first motion was effectively denied, that was like denying a new trial motion, which is an appealable order that divests the court of jurisdiction to act further.

Problem is, an order that foresees further action by the trial court is not a judgment even if it has the word “judgment” in its title. (I really wish trial courts wouldn’t do that because of the chaos it tends to create, but it happens all the time.) So a post-verdict, pre-judgment motion directed to a remedy within the province of the trial court was entirely proper. And then when a legit final judgment did enter, a § 663 motion was an appropriate vehicle for defendant to use to have it corrected.

Affirmed.

Monday, September 8, 2014

Vacating the Vacatur to Consider Missing Conflict Disclosures

United Health Centers of the San Joaquin Valley v. Superior Court, No. F067763 (D5 Aug. 25, 2014)

Due to apparent shoddy recordkeeping, the arbitrator in this case failed to disclose all of the conflicts information required by Code of Civil Procedure § 1281.9. The question is, whether the omissions from the disclosure were sufficient reason to vacate the arbitrator’s award. As the court here explains, that turns on an issue of waiver, which itself depends on whether the plaintiff had reason to know that the disclosures were incomplete when the arbitration commenced.


Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Judgment in Mineral Dispute Stays Put in State Court

Tearlach Resources Ltd. v. Western States International, Inc., No. F065511 (D5, as amended Sept. 17, 2013) 

The trial court entered judgment in a case about a dispute over an oil and gas lease on federal land. It subsequently granted a motion to vacate the judgment under Code of Civil Procedure § 473(d) on the grounds that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction to enter the judgment because it believed that the claim was subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal courts. The court of appeal reversed, holding that (a) federal court jurisdiction is exclusive only when a statute expressly provides that result; (b) that the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920, which governed the claims at issue, did not provide for exclusive federal jurisdiction; and (c) because the dispute was just a contract dispute between lessees and assignees, the interests of the United States were not sufficiently implicated to make it a necessary party, such as to require exclusive federal jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1346(f), which vests the federal courts with exclusive jurisdiction to actions to quiet title to real property in which the United States claims an interest.

Reversed.

We've Moved ....

After a two-year hiatus,  111 North Hill Street  has decided to decamp for Substack. Thank you for your readership over the last twelve year...