Monster Energy Co. v. Schechter, No. S251392 (Cal. Jul. 11, 2019)
About a year ago, the Court of Appeal held in this case that an attorney couldn’t be bound by a confidentiality clause in a settlement agreement because, notwithstanding the confi’s application to “the parties and their attorneys, the attorneys signed only as “approved as to form and content.” The Supreme Court reverses. The posture of the case is an anti-SLAPP motion so the plaintiffs only need to show “minimal merit,” i.e., make a prima facie showing on the issue. The Supreme Court finds (unanimously) that because the substantive provisions of the agreement contained several provisions that purported to bind the attorneys, a reasonable trier of fact could find that the attorneys agreed to be bound, notwithstanding the signatures being limited to approvals. That was enough to fend off an anti-SLAPP challenge.
Court of Appeal reversed.
Showing posts with label monster energy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label monster energy. Show all posts
Monday, August 19, 2019
Tuesday, August 14, 2018
Approved as to Form and Content
Monster Energy Co. v. Schechter, No. E066267 (D4d2 Aug. 13, 2108)
A settlement agreement at issue in this case obliged "the parties and their attorneys” to keep the settlement confidential. Plaintiff’s attorney signed the agreement, but only “approved as to form and content.” He then proceeded to tell a shady media outlet (which might have been controlled by his firm) about the settlement. Defendant sued the attorney. But the Court of Appeal held that the agreement didn’t actually bind the attorney. The client couldn't bind the attorney, just by adding them into the agreement. And the attorney's signing under "approved as to form and content” language was not an assent by the attorney to be bound. Which means a SLAPP motion prevailed because the claim couldn't succeed.
The lesson here is clear: If you are facing an Avenatti, he needs to actually agree to be a party to the confi, or else your only remedy is going to be against Stormy.
Reversed.
A settlement agreement at issue in this case obliged "the parties and their attorneys” to keep the settlement confidential. Plaintiff’s attorney signed the agreement, but only “approved as to form and content.” He then proceeded to tell a shady media outlet (which might have been controlled by his firm) about the settlement. Defendant sued the attorney. But the Court of Appeal held that the agreement didn’t actually bind the attorney. The client couldn't bind the attorney, just by adding them into the agreement. And the attorney's signing under "approved as to form and content” language was not an assent by the attorney to be bound. Which means a SLAPP motion prevailed because the claim couldn't succeed.
The lesson here is clear: If you are facing an Avenatti, he needs to actually agree to be a party to the confi, or else your only remedy is going to be against Stormy.
Reversed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
We've Moved ....
After a two-year hiatus, 111 North Hill Street has decided to decamp for Substack. Thank you for your readership over the last twelve year...
-
Soto v. Borgwarner Morse Tec Inc. , No. B252995 (D2d4, as modified August 20, 2015) Although some law-and-economics attuned federal judges...
-
The Rossdale Grp. v. Walton , No. H043476 (D6 Apr. 15, 2017) This is a weird and kind of narrow opinion about standing that is mostly shap...